What to do when a newcomer gets the promotion you wanted

Missing out on a promotion can be discouraging or disappointing, especially when the role goes to an external candidate. However, this doesn’t have to hold back your career. Recruitment specialist Robert Walters shares practical tips to help you come out stronger from this situation and increase your chances of future career growth.

1. Don’t take it personally

Promotions are often influenced by multiple factors and don’t always reflect your talent or potential. Sometimes, organizations choose a new colleague because they bring specific experience or knowledge that is immediately applicable in a rapidly changing market. This doesn’t mean your skills are any less valuable. Use this as an opportunity to reflect: what new skills can you develop to position yourself even more strongly for the next opportunity?

2. Talk about it

It’s normal to feel emotional after missing out on a promotion, but acting impulsively – like resigning on the spot – is rarely a wise decision. Instead, have an open conversation with your manager and ask for feedback about why the external candidate was chosen. Approach the discussion with an open mind and avoid criticizing the decision. Constructive feedback can provide valuable insights into which skills or experiences you may need to strengthen.

3. Collaborate with the new manager

An external hire can also present opportunities: they often bring fresh perspectives and different leadership styles. Take the time to get to know your new manager and see what you can learn from them. This not only helps sharpen your own skills but also increases your visibility within the team.

4. Demonstrate leadership without a title

Leadership isn’t just about holding a title or position; it’s about influence and collaboration.

Take initiative, suggest improvements, or mentor colleagues who could benefit from your guidance. By actively contributing to your team’s success, you build credibility and establish yourself as a future leader.

5. Give it time

Allow both yourself and the new manager some time to adjust before drawing conclusions about your future at the company. During this period, focus on demonstrating flexibility, teamwork, and your ability to add value – qualities that are crucial for securing promotions in the long run.

6. Keep evaluating your opportunities

If, after some time, you find that growth opportunities within your current organization remain limited, it might be worth exploring options outside of the company. Make sure you have a clear vision of your long-term career goals and only pursue external offers that truly align with your ambitions.

More information

Discover our career advice blog. Looking to move roles? Check out our most recent jobs or contact one of our offices.